juillet 15, 2004

what's an education? GET ONE.

i'm finding it hard to swallow the accusation that bill cosby is treacherous to his ethnic group because he abhors the fact that there are certain sects of it that espouse their ignorance as though it were an anthem. this affliction does not encompass the entirety, and it is not purely the province of that singular group--i don't wish to be labeled racist here. but the fact is that there is a large group of people (of all colors) who appear to have no care whatsoever about the fact that they can't construct a proper sentence, or read; there are many who take pride in it, revering media figures who demonstrate the same lack of erudition and thus perpetuate the problem. and--and this is what gets me--many refuse to accept that it is that apathy that is keeping them down. it is not 'the man' that is keeping them poor and humbled; it is their own ignorance.

i agree with the remarks that cosby made several weeks ago, and for which he has been lambasted since--if you don't learn to read, or to speak properly, you don't get the luxury of blaming society for your failure to advance, to get a job, to do what you want in life. this goes for everyone, in every ethnic group, in every economic bracket. you don't need an expensive education to get ahead. you don't need to go ivy league, or get a phd. plenty of people do just fine with a high school education; some with even less. but these are almost all people who have learned that in order to advance, they needed to be able to read, and speak: skills that can be gleaned through even a partial basic public education.

perhaps i'm a snob. after all, it's all well and good for a middle-class white girl with a college degree from a respected institution and a well-rounded upbringing to bang on about literacy and the need to speak properly. and of course i'm preaching to the choir; if you're a blogger, or a blog reader, presumably you have learned how to interact with words in such a way that you can turn them to your advantage. but it infuriates me to see, interact with or hear about people who have the raw material that it takes to get where they want, but prefer to leave it to fester in pits of apathy and rage and then blame society for their failings. and, more importantly, give up and resign themselves to this life that they loathe. because it's a waste. a waste of energy and a waste of talent.

ignorance is not an anthem. it is nothing to be proud of. and i think bill cosby is right. and maybe i'm an elitist. maybe i'm not being realistic. but in addition to not understanding how people can be allowed to make it to adulthood without being able to read--PARTICULARLY in this country, still unquestionably the richest in the world, which SHOULD be able to support at least that most basic of educational infrastructures--i can't fathom how anyone would be content going through life without such a wonderful skill.

but then, i do have an irrational love of words. and an education.

Posted by shivery at juillet 15, 2004 10:39 AM
Comments

I also agree with the Cos, and he should be given the benefit of the doubt by his critics even if what he's saying is coming out so passionately that it isn't PC or "nice." He's trying to shock people out of complacence and get them to take action; and he's more than entitled to do so because of his commitment to educational programming and the creative energy he's channeled into this effort. It must be frustrating for him to see the current trends.

Posted by: jen at juillet 15, 2004 12:24 PM

Ya know one of the most powerful things I read that he said was this:

"Dogs, water hoses that tear the bark off trees, Emmett Till," he said, naming the black youth who was tortured and murdered in Mississippi in 1955, allegedly for whistling at a white woman. "And you're going to tell me you're going to drop out of school? You're going to tell me you're going to steal from a store?"

I don't have any experience with being black in America but he sure as hell does and he has a right to speak his truth.

Posted by: Miss Bliss at juillet 15, 2004 03:51 PM

I also agree with his remarks in the general sense, BUT his willingness to articulate that point and NOT lay bare the system of instutitionalized class and race discrimination that stacks the deck against certain groups is a sadly missed opportunity. It's not just individuals who make the difference; it's the environment that surrounds around them, which is not always subject to those individuals' control. Both factors need to be considered in regards to the problem.

Posted by: Greg at juillet 15, 2004 06:57 PM

i say as long as you learn how to speak properly, you can talk however you want. education gives you the choice to articulate your thoughts however you choose. once you have that foundation, you can speak in grammatically correct english, or you can speak in the way that is favored by your community (and the issues here are much more complicated and multifaceted than simply 'lack of education' or 'espousing ignorance as an anthem').

Posted by: steph at juillet 16, 2004 01:21 PM

agreed, steph. of course the issues have more depth and complexity than i paint them with here--but then, let's not forget: i'm just ranting. the point is to make people think, not to be right, necessarily.

my great concern is with people who *willfully* keep themselves ignorant, and then blame others for not being able to get ahead.

Posted by: shivery at juillet 16, 2004 01:25 PM